The Club at Nevillewood vs Treesdale Golf & Country Club
The Club at Nevillewood (Presto, Collier Township, 1992, Jack Nicklaus) and Treesdale Golf & Country Club (Gibsonia/Mars, 1994, Arnold Palmer) are the two clearest examples of the residential_integration model in the Pittsburgh market -- both purpose-built in the early-to-mid 1990s specifically as the centerpiece of a new residential community, in contrast to the region's much older freestanding private clubs. But they are not the same model: Treesdale is explicitly documented as Western Pennsylvania's first true master-planned community with a large, two-county footprint and a clear split between neighborhood-wide and club-only amenities, while Nevillewood is a smaller, single-township custom-home community with its own HOA and a distinct resident-membership category referenced in club bylaws.
Side by Side
How They Compare
Designer
The Club at Nevillewood
Jack Nicklaus (1992)
Treesdale Golf & Country Club
Arnold Palmer (1994)
Holes
The Club at Nevillewood
18
Treesdale Golf & Country Club
27
Community scale
The Club at Nevillewood
Single township (Collier Twp., Allegheny Co.)
Treesdale Golf & Country Club
~1,400 acres, ~1,000 home sites, spans Allegheny and Butler counties
Marketed distinction
The Club at Nevillewood
Custom-home community with its own HOA
Treesdale Golf & Country Club
Documented as Western PA's first master-planned community
Non-golf amenities available without club membership
The Club at Nevillewood
Not confirmed this session
Treesdale Golf & Country Club
Yes -- pool, courts, fields, and trails at 'The Commons' are resident-wide
Golf membership required for homeowners
The Club at Nevillewood
Unconfirmed / conflicting sourcing
Treesdale Golf & Country Club
No -- confirmed as a separate purchase from home ownership
Designer & Course
Nevillewood's 18-hole course is a full Jack Nicklaus Signature design (1992), playing to roughly 7,228 yards -- one of relatively few complete Nicklaus designs in Western Pennsylvania. Treesdale's course is a 27-hole Arnold Palmer design (opened 1994), giving it nine more holes and a larger overall course footprint across its 1,400-acre community.
Community Scale & Structure
Treesdale spans roughly 1,400 acres and about 1,000 home sites across two counties -- Gibsonia/Pine Township in Allegheny County and Mars/Adams Township in Butler County -- and is explicitly marketed as the first master-planned community in Western Pennsylvania. Nevillewood is a smaller, single-township community in Collier Township (Allegheny County), governed by its own dedicated homeowners association (nevillewoodhoa.com); a precise home-site count was not found this session.
How Golf Access Relates to Homeownership
Treesdale draws an explicit, documented line: neighborhood-wide amenities at a shared facility called 'The Commons' (pool, tennis, pickleball, basketball, volleyball, sports fields, walking paths) are available to every resident regardless of club membership, while golf itself requires separate club membership -- not included with a home purchase. Nevillewood's structure is less fully documented: club bylaws reference a distinct 'Resident Golf Membership' category versus a 'Non-Resident Golf Membership' category, and an HOA covenant references a specific membership policy resolution, but whether resident golf membership is actually mandatory for every Nevillewood homeowner was not confirmed in this research pass for either community -- a buyer should verify current terms directly with each HOA and club before assuming either is bundled or fully optional.
Trying to Choose Between The Club at Nevillewood and Treesdale Golf & Country Club?
A local real-estate specialist can walk you through the tradeoffs and current availability at each.
US Golf Living provides independent real-estate research and can connect consumers with real-estate professionals. Golf membership, availability, fees and approval are determined independently by the applicable club.