US Golf Living

Hawthorn Woods Country Club vs Ivanhoe Club for Golf Living

Hawthorn Woods Country Club and Ivanhoe Club, both in Lake County's Libertyville/Mundelein-area exurb cluster, look similar on the surface -- gated communities built directly around a private course -- but their membership structures could not be more different. One is Illinois's cleanest confirmed mandatory-bundling case; the other keeps membership a separate, standard equity purchase.

Side by Side

How They Compare

Membership requirement for homeowners

Hawthorn Woods Country Club

Mandatory: every homeowner must carry at least a $416/month Social Membership

Hawthorn Woods Country Club

Not required; standard equity membership is a separate, optional application

Course

Hawthorn Woods Country Club

18 holes, Arnold Palmer/Ed Seay design

Hawthorn Woods Country Club

27 holes (three 9-hole courses), Dick Nugent/Arthur Hills design

Competitive golf pedigree

Hawthorn Woods Country Club

None found

Hawthorn Woods Country Club

Hosted the Korn Ferry Tour's Rust-Oleum Championship, 2016-2018; ranked Top 20 in Illinois by Golf Digest

Community structure

Hawthorn Woods Country Club

One gated, roughly 600-home Toll Brothers community (2004-2009)

Hawthorn Woods Country Club

Two separately-gated communities (Woods of Ivanhoe, Ivanhoe Estates) sharing the course

Club operator

Hawthorn Woods Country Club

KemperSports (national club management company)

Hawthorn Woods Country Club

Member-owned equity club

Confirmed mandatory homeowner golf cost

Hawthorn Woods Country Club

$416/month minimum, confirmed on the club's own site

Hawthorn Woods Country Club

None; initiation fee and dues not published, and not confirmed as mandatory

Membership Model: Mandatory vs Separate

Hawthorn Woods Country Club is unambiguous: the club's own site states every homeowner must carry at least a $416/month Social Membership as a condition of living in the community, a mandatory cost confirmed directly on hwccgolf.com. Ivanhoe Club is the opposite case -- its own Join page describes a standard Regular Equity Golf Membership requiring an initiation fee and dues, open to qualified applicants generally, with no confirmed automatic or required tie to owning a home in either the Woods of Ivanhoe or Ivanhoe Estates, the two gated communities built around its 27 holes.

The Golf Itself

Hawthorn Woods offers a single 18-hole Arnold Palmer/Ed Seay design, among the duo's last collaborations. Ivanhoe Club offers considerably more golf variety: 27 holes across three distinct 9-hole courses (Dick Nugent and Arthur Hills design) spanning prairie, forest, and ravine terrain, a layout that has ranked in Illinois's Top 20 and hosted the Korn Ferry Tour's Rust-Oleum Championship from 2016 to 2018 -- stronger competitive-golf pedigree than Hawthorn Woods, though Hawthorn Woods carries the more famous designer name in Arnold Palmer.

Community Structure

Hawthorn Woods Country Club is a single, roughly 600-home Toll Brothers-built gated community (2004-2009). Ivanhoe Club instead anchors two separately-named and apparently separately-governed gated communities -- the Woods of Ivanhoe (under the Ivanhoe Club Property Owners Association, Inc.) and Ivanhoe Estates -- giving a buyer more sub-market choice around the same course, at the cost of a less unified community identity than Hawthorn Woods.

What This Means for Your Search

A buyer who wants certainty -- guaranteed community-wide golf-club amenities as part of the deal, with no separate application process -- should weight Hawthorn Woods Country Club more heavily, but should budget for the mandatory $416/month minimum (before any golf-tier upgrade) as a real, unavoidable carrying cost. A buyer who wants more course variety and flexibility, and who is comfortable applying separately (and paying an unpublished initiation fee and dues) for golf access, should weight Ivanhoe Club more heavily, keeping in mind that neither Woods of Ivanhoe nor Ivanhoe Estates guarantees that membership as part of the purchase. Confirm current fees at both directly with the respective clubs before deciding -- Hawthorn Woods' $416/month figure and Ivanhoe Club's unpublished equity-membership costs are both subject to change.

Trying to Choose Between Hawthorn Woods Country Club and Hawthorn Woods Country Club?

A local real-estate specialist can walk you through the tradeoffs and current availability at each.

US Golf Living provides independent real-estate research and can connect consumers with real-estate professionals. Golf membership, availability, fees and approval are determined independently by the applicable club.