Toftrees vs. Centre Hills Country Club: Two Ways to Buy Golf Living in State College
Toftrees and Centre Hills Country Club are State College's only two qualifying golf anchors researched by this platform, and they could hardly work more differently. Below is what actually distinguishes them for a golf-oriented buyer.
Side by Side
How They Compare
Golf access model
Toftrees Golf Resort
Public/daily-fee; optional paid membership tier open to anyone.
Centre Hills Country Club
Fully private, application-based membership; confirmed initiation fee and dues (amounts undisclosed).
Founded
Toftrees Golf Resort
Late 1960s (course opened 1968-69, Ed Ault design).
Centre Hills Country Club
1921 (27-hole facility).
Holes
Toftrees Golf Resort
18
Centre Hills Country Club
27
Residential pattern
Toftrees Golf Resort
Deliberately planned from the start (Pennsylvania's first planned community): townhomes, single-family homes, apartments, plus an age-restricted retirement community.
Centre Hills Country Club
Organically developed single-family neighborhood (Kissinger family) that grew around and was named for the pre-existing private club.
Non-golf amenities
Toftrees Golf Resort
Resort hotel, conference center, on-site restaurant (The Field).
Centre Hills Country Club
Clubhouse dining, tennis, pickleball, swimming.
Gated
Toftrees Golf Resort
Unknown -- not confirmed either way.
Centre Hills Country Club
Unknown -- not confirmed either way.
How You Actually Get Golf Access
Toftrees' golf course is public and daily-fee -- anyone can play, resident or not, and an optional paid membership tier (unlimited range/short-game access, pro-shop and dining discounts) is open to the general public with no residency requirement. Centre Hills Country Club is the opposite: per its own centennial coverage, it is the only fully private country club in Centre County, with application-based membership, initiation fees and dues confirmed to exist and vary by class (though amounts are not publicly disclosed), and full clubhouse privileges (golf, tennis, pickleball, swimming, dining) reserved for members and their immediate families.
The Residential Pattern Is Different Too
Toftrees is a single, deliberately planned development from the start -- Pennsylvania's first planned community, per widely repeated descriptions -- with the golf course as its organizing feature and a genuine mix of townhomes, single-family homes, and apartments (plus the adjoining age-restricted Village at Penn State) built directly into that plan. Centre Hills reads as a more traditional pattern: an organically developed, single-family neighborhood (developed by the Kissinger family) that grew up around and took its name from an already-established private club, with its largest homes commanding real course frontage.
What This Means for Your Search
A buyer who wants guaranteed golf access with no membership barrier, at the cost of playing a public course rather than a private one, and who values Toftrees' resort amenities (hotel, restaurant, and a major course renovation announced in 2025) fits Toftrees better. A buyer who wants the exclusivity and social structure of a genuinely private, century-old club -- and is prepared to apply and pay confirmed-but-undisclosed initiation fees and dues -- fits Centre Hills better. Neither model includes golf automatically with a home purchase; the real difference is whether golf itself is open to anyone (Toftrees) or gated behind membership (Centre Hills).
Trying to Choose Between Toftrees Golf Resort and Centre Hills Country Club?
A local real-estate specialist can walk you through the tradeoffs and current availability at each.
US Golf Living provides independent real-estate research and can connect consumers with real-estate professionals. Golf membership, availability, fees and approval are determined independently by the applicable club.